Skip to content

COOPERSTOWN SELECT DISTINGUISHED WHISKEY

Cooperstown Select Straight Bourbon Whiskey

2020 95 Points “Liquid Gold” – Jim Murray’s Whisky Bible
2020 96 – The Tasting Panel
2019
95 Points “Liquid Gold” – Jim Murray’s Whisky Bible
2018 Double Gold – Best Bourbon – 50 Best
2017 Gold – Denver International Spirits Competition

Our most highly acclaimed and celebrated bourbon stands out among even the finest whiskeys in the world. Aged at least three years in choice oak barrels, it is masterfully-crafted from a highly unique four grain mash bill made exclusively from local New York State grains. It is a remarkably soft and delicate bourbon. A true masterpiece worthy of its many past awards and world-class reputation.

100 Proof       Available in 750 ml. bottles.

Cooperstown Select Straight Rye Whiskey

2020 Gold – USA Spirits Ratings 96 points
2020 96 Points – The Tasting Panel
2019 Gold – John Barleycorn Awards
2018 Gold – NY World Wine & Spirits
2018 Gold Medal – Artisan Awards Competition
2018 Gold Rye Whiskey – 50 Best

This distinguished straight rye whiskey is hand-crafted from rye and other grains which are 100% locally grown in New York State. Aged two to three years, this rye begins its journey in new American oak barrels and is then finished for at least one year in used Cabernet Sauvignon barrels.  Notably bottled at cask strength, this impressive rye is incredibly complex and compares favorably to even the most prestigious names in the category.    

102 Proof       Available in 750 ml. bottles.

Cooperstown Select American Blended Whiskey

2020 96 Points – The Tasting Panel
2020
91 Points – Jim Murray’s Whisky Bible
2019 91 Points – Jim Murray’s Whisky Bible

This highly unique American blended whiskey is made entirely from local New York State grains and patiently aged in hand-picked oak barrels.  Made of nothing but 100% American whiskey, it is subtly matured and expertly blended to perfection. It is finished with French Oak for up to a year which conveys a very soft and graceful whiskey.  Enjoy it neat or on the rocks for a truly unique sipping experience!

90 Proof       Available in 750 ml. bottles.

THE BASEBALL LINEUP

Abner Doubleday's Bourbon
2019 International Review of Spirits Packaging Competition
Gold Medal- Creativity Category
Gold Medal- Form Category
Gold Medal-Style Category
Best Gift Box

A blend of young and 5 year old bourbons, it drinks remarkably well, like a fine “older” bourbon should. Filled in our patented, specialty baseball decanter, this bourbon makes a great sipping spirit.

Pine cases are available and sold separately in our merchandise store.
90 Proof       Available in 750 ml. bottles.

Abner Doubleday's Double Play Vodka

2014 Double Gold – Manhattan Fifty Best Vodka Competition
2014 Gold – Dallas World Spirits Competition Summer
2014 Gold – Denver International Spirits Competition Spring

Our award-winning, premium Vodka made from 100% wheat in a unique hand-blown glass decanter bottle. Each bottle is designed in the shape of a baseball, right down to the 108 seam stitches! An exceptionally smooth, premium vodka and a one-of-a-kind piece!

Pine cases are available and sold separately in our merchandise store.
80 Proof       Available in 750 ml. bottles.

Abner Doubleday's American Whiskey

This beautiful handmade whiskey has been aged for 10 months in used American oak bourbon barrels. Done in a lighter style and filled in our patented, specialty baseball decanter, it is a remarkably smooth-drinking whiskey.

Pine cases are available and sold separately in our merchandise store.
90 Proof       Available in 750 ml. bottles.

The Triple Play

This unique 3-pack comes in a handy cardboard gift box and includes a full lineup of our Abner Doubleday premium craft spirits: Bourbon, Double Play Vodka and American Whiskey.  Each comes in our patented, hand blown Baseball Bottle.  An extraordinary value!

Pine cases are available and sold separately in our merchandise store.
Available in boxes of (3) 750 ml. bottles.

The Mini Triple Play

A two-pack “mini” version of our famous Triple Play. Includes 50ml baseball bottles of our Abner Doubleday premium craft spirits: Bourbon, Double Play Vodka and American Whiskey.  

Available in 2 boxes of (3) 50 ml. bottles.

Spitball Cinnamon Whiskey

This complex cinnamon whiskey is named “Spitball” as a nod to the controversial baseball pitch during the early days of the game. With 50% less sugar content than mass marketed competitors, whiskey connoisseurs can enjoy this spirit straight, on the rocks, or as a mixer in Manhattans or Whiskey Sours.

70 Proof       Available in 750 ml. bottles.

Beanball Bourbon

2018 Drammie – Best Whiskey Value
2014
Gold – Manhattan Fifty Best Bourbon Competition
2014 87 Points – Whisky Advocate Summer

A hand-crafted blend that adds a degree of softness on the palette while creating layers of depth and complexity.  Our distiller decided to bump this up slightly in proof in order to accentuate the finish notes on this thoroughly enjoyable spirit.

90 Proof       Available in 750 ml. bottles.

PREMIUM COOPERSTOWN COLLECTION

Glimmerglass Vodka

2016 Double Gold Best Vodka – 50 Best

Made from 100% soft spring wheat, this exceptionally smooth vodka is distilled six times, then charcoal-filtered twice using our unique custom filtration process.  This vodka drinks with a soft mouth feel that defies description.

80 Proof.   Available in 750 ml bottles.

Fenimore Gin

2020 Gold – John Barleycorn Award
2018 92 Points – The Tasting Panel
2017
Double Gold – Best Gin – 50 Best
2014
Gold – Manhattan Fifty Best Gin Competition

A lovingly handcrafted recipe of fourteen botanicals. Includes Juniper Berry and citrus peel, but turns the corner with the more esoteric botanicals like Eucalyptus, Chamomile, Star Anise, and native New York Lilac. This craft style gin will please both the traditional and non-traditional gin drinker.

80 Proof       Available in 750 ml. bottles.

Lafite French Traders Gin

2019 Gold Best Gin – 50 Best

This enticing gin is aged in our used bourbon barrels. During the aging process, it begins to pick up undertones of a fine whiskey and acquires a slight amber color. This three year-old old barreled gin, made from 100% white winter wheat, is distilled by hot vapor extraction with no maceration.

90 Proof       Available in 375 ml. bottles.

Sam Smith's Boatyard Rum

2020 Gold Best Aged Rum – 50 Best
2019 Gold Best Rum – 50 Best

Made from 100% non-GMO sugar cane, this Caribbean-style rum is aged a minimum of two years. It drinks delightfully smooth with soft spice notes on the nose and the faintest hint of vanilla on the finish. A classy, sophisticated rum.

86 Proof       Available in 750 ml. bottles.

Cane High Spiced Rum

2020 Gold – USA Spirits Ratings

A spiced rum with distinction. A proprietary blend of exotic Chai-style spices infused with our two-year-old amber rum. This intriguing mix steers away from the mainstream creating an uncommon spirit with enticing substance and real character.

86 Proof       Available in 750 ml. bottles.